I learned a new requirement that now the rollups must be filtered on a third criteria. (This will mean creating 62 new fields to capture the rollups... but I digress). So I added this new, tertiary criteria.
However, it's not working. I have checked and re-checked and re-re-checked. New criteria in circled in red on the image. Prior to adding the new criteria, the rollup was working across all opptys that met the stage and competing criteria.
I ran a query with those criteria to ensure there are records that meet them, and that I wasn't missing something.